Im not hating man, if you like it then thats all that maters. I dont like the industrial look of the top of the radiator, all the fins are exposed (it looks to me incomplete), your overflow line spans way too far for me... For the extra price of an aluminum one (even if you painted it black) I think you get more out of it. Hell, just re-core the stock one into a a 3 pass if you want subtlety. To me, the VW radiator doesnt look like it belongs at all.
But thats the beauty of this forum, everyone has different parts and different builds.