Thanks for the replies. @datzenmike i put in the new resistor but the AC shuts off when I move the lever to the 4th speed, which must be what you were saying initially, that 3 is somehow the high setting - which may go with charlie69's point directly above. @Charlie69 if I understand correctly, you think the blower motor itself won’t go to the 4th speed? That some just do 3 speeds? I've seen climate controls with just the three speeds, so I wonder if I accidentally got a replacement blower motor out of a truck that only had three speeds. Weird that my old one only did three speeds too, but for all I know, that might not have been the original either. If this is the maximum this blower motor can do, I'll just live with it I guess. For reference, here’s what my climate control looks like: