Jump to content
ol' 320

Anyone want to buy new 320 vent window rubbers?

Recommended Posts

My point in raising this topic from the dead was to point out that you could use the 3D printer to help with the mold making process. 3D print one example and test fit it. If it fits, then move on to 3D printing the mold. From there we could send the 3D printed mold (and the file) to a mold making company, like my friend in AZ, and have a mold made in aluminum. From there, having them poured is the easy part.

 

It sounds like Marouk (Phil Muffet) on here has been doing CAD work on the part--maybe he'd be willing to share the file?

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post

It sounds like Marouk (Phil Muffet) on here has been doing CAD work on the part--maybe he'd be willing to share the file?

 

It sounds like he has put a lot of his time and effort into that with an ends to have a commercial product. I would not feel right in asking for a file that would undercut his efforts. Just doesn't sit right with me.

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post

I meant no disrespect to Phil. I'd be happy to pay him for a set to help him recoup some of his time. 

 

I only mentioned it because he said he's not interested in producing in mass or trying to turn a buck. He also said he'd be happy if someone figures out the gaskets first. I'm not suggesting anyone undercut anyone else's efforts. 

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post

I have a decent vent window rubber gasket if one wants to borrow it for scanning etc.

 

Richard Kramer

707-260-5327

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post

I am also interested in a few sets.  Very essential thing to have during restoration...and we all hate that darn window noise.  

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post

Unfortunately Phil Marouk has not logged in here for more than 60 days. I tried PM'ing him when he started this thread and received no reply.

 

I am no longer in a position to participate in  big way in the creation of these parts as I have moved on to other projects, but my buddy, the one who bought my 320, would certainly buy a set. I think Dguy210 and Matt S. said it best a few posts ago. If someone has the gumption to at least scan and build a file of a left and right vent rubber this project would be much farther down the road.

 

My point in raising this topic from the dead was to point out that you could use the 3D printer to help with the mold making process. 3D print one example and test fit it. If it fits, then move on to 3D printing the mold. From there we could send the 3D printed mold (and the file) to a mold making company, like my friend in AZ, and have a mold made in aluminum. From there, having them poured is the easy part.

 

It is easy to state what another should do, but until either someone with silly money comes forward to reproduce these, the only way this will likely move forward is if an insider who is experienced with 3d printing is willing to take this on, nothing will happen.

 

Dguy210: I met you some time ago at Dave Pare's place when I drove my 320 up there. If you decide to take this on, PM me and I might be willing to make a token contribution to an effort to scan and print a trial set. If it works, it works. if it doesn't, then there would be no obligation or expectation at all to produce anything.

 

Datzenmike: Don't get too excited, we aren't talking about diving down the road that happened with king cab rubbers:) I am just offering to consider offsetting some of the material costs to 3d print a trial pair of these or to help get a good set of scans so they could be printed - should Dguy210 be interested in trying this. 

 

The fellow Richard who left his number above appears to have at least one side in good shape that could be scanned. I have no idea if he has a set of left and right vent rubbers.

 

If Phil Marouk is still reading Ratsun posts, but just not logging in, please PM me. My email is in my profile.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post

This thread moves faster than I do, unfortunately.

 

Apologies for the absence. I had been off being distracted in general with work and other projects and then locked myself out the site (long story short - use the right username and email and it unlocks really easy. Use the wrong one and you'll drive yourself nuts).

 

No real progress on the vent rubbers. It is at a frustrating stage where I need a few hours run at it and time is pressed. Hopefully, with the slow down over Christmas, i can get the time to run off the latest mold and see how close it gets us. 

  • Like 3

Share this post


Link to post

Take your time, no one else is doing anything about this issue we have, over here everyone wants everything done yesterday except when they have to do it.
I looked into this way back, but the guy I talked to in Australia had a reputation for taking peoples money and then having nothing but excuses when it didn't work out, my friend said the guy had someone in Asia make some of the best reproduction rubber pieces out there, but he told me don't give the guy any money up front, but it was alright to buy the stuff he had on ebay as the parts already existed.

Share this post


Link to post

This thread moves faster than I do, unfortunately.

 

Apologies for the absence. I had been off being distracted in general with work and other projects and then locked myself out the site (long story short - use the right username and email and it unlocks really easy. Use the wrong one and you'll drive yourself nuts).

 

No real progress on the vent rubbers. It is at a frustrating stage where I need a few hours run at it and time is pressed. Hopefully, with the slow down over Christmas, i can get the time to run off the latest mold and see how close it gets us. 

Marouk you're a hero! Thanks for sticking with it.

Share this post


Link to post

Wayno - I had a simple rule at my wedding that unless you are paying for it you don't get to push your opinion. Same reason why I don't take 'investment' from others on projects I am not making money on! I'm 90% certain I have dealt with your mate's mate. He is well known in other manufacturer club circles for helping to produce a part at your expense, only to have it turn up en masse at a cheaper price. Shame...as he clearly has the bandwidth and contacts to make it happen.

 

320 Newb - I'm a firm believer to hold the applause until the act finishes, you never know whats coming!! 

 

I've said it before - I'm confident in getting a result, its the time it'll take given the priority of this that's in doubt!!

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post

I suspect we are talking about the same guy, some of the best reproduction rubber parts out there, then they show up on ebay in the US for half the price.

 

Here is most of my post earlier in this thread(post 98) below.

 

 

 

I actually got a quote from a guy for 320 wingwindow molds a couple days ago, then I asked a friend of mine over in Australia about the guy, this is what I received from him, I am going to change the name of the company/person right now, I will refer to him as "THE GUY", it's not likely that I will be sending money to THE GUY to have molds made, if he is selling finished parts on ebay, I will buy them just like everyone else, but I am not paying for molds.

 

G'day Wayne,

                      Mate........................BIG story. I'll just give you the highlights. Now alot of this story has nothing to do with me.  But this guy THE GUY has around $4000 worth of stainless mouldings for my Monaro, and i will never get it back.
 
OK, so the story goes that this guy THE GUY was doing repro rubber parts for Japanese cars, and good quality stuff too. He was getting them done in Thailand.  
Now these guys in Thailand are also doing repro stuff for other people, including car panels for U.S. cars like Camaro's etc and selling to a particular guy in the states. 
 
The story goes, someone in the states got onto the guys in Thailand, and paid big money to make tooling for these parts. In return, they were to be the sole supplier of said parts, but.......... the guys in Thailand are dishonest, and sold some of this stuff to THE GUY "out the back door" 
Shame on them for selling someone else's product, 
and shame on THE GUY for doing the deal with them.
So then THE GUY says to the guys in Thailand, i want a heap of early Holden parts reproduced, how about you do them for me?  Of course the guys in Thailand say "sure, you pay for the tooling and we will do it."
So they start off small and he gets some good parts, gets them into Australia and he is the sole supplier of these parts.  More and more tooling gets made and paid for, more and more parts are coming in, THE GUY is making a killing.
So guess what happens!!!!!
Some guys in Australia go to the same back door that THE GUY went to, and THEY start buying repro Holden parts from Thailand.
So THE GUY is now on the receiving end of losing out. He gets the legal stuff happening, and that is where it is at right now.
 
How do i know all of this i hear you ask.....
 
Well, a while ago i find a HQ Holden Monaro coupe.  Has all this good stuff with it, but the body is in a panel shop, the upholstery is at the trimmers, and the stainless mouldings are at a reputable dealers place. I visit all of these places to inspect all of the items that belong to the car. So the guy that has the stainless says,"no worries, your stainless is at THE GUYS place, we just need to get it back here" It's all reconditioned ready to put on.
So i buy the car, do the rounds to pick up all of the parts for my car, but THE GUY hasn't got the stainless at his shop, he has sent them to Thailand to be used for templates.
OK, so i want my parts please i  say.  "Well, about that, he says, i can't get them for you as all of this shit is going on right now. I acknowledge you own these parts, and i am doing my best to get them back for you but i am having trouble" 
These parts for the Monaro coupe are super hard to find, and a full set is generally worth $4000. And they don't come up very often.
So there is hundreds of thousands of dollars worth of stuff that people like me have unwittingly loaned out that will never get it back
 
So, if you are asking my opinion on you doing a deal with THE GUY???? 
NOT ON YOUR LIFE!!!!!!
Buying stuff from him off ebay would be fine. But trusting this guy with $3000, would be like giving a fat kid the keys to a chocolate shop.
With you being in the states, he would have no reason to honor anything for you, because you will never come to Australia to retrieve $3K. 
I think you are most likely in a very hard spot, especially since you are overseas.
If i can help in any way just ask, it is no problem.
  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post

I would be interested in one or two sets, ie one for sure and a second depending on the price..........ooppps, should have read the entire thread before posting

Share this post


Link to post

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

×

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.